Satisfactory Academic Progress: What Students Experience

A national look at how SAP requirements affect college students’ financial aid eligibility and the pathways available when students struggle to meet SAP requirements.

Explore how students experience SAP nationally

Satisfactory Academic Progress (SAP) requirements play an important role in determining whether college students maintain access to federal financial aid, yet institutions have substantial flexibility in how those requirements are implemented and how students are supported. This interactive dashboard highlights findings from a national evaluation of SAP policies and student outcomes, including who struggles to meet requirements, how policies vary across institutions, and what happens when students are at risk of losing aid.

Download Evaluation
View by institution type
The scale of SAP failure

More than one in ten undergraduate students nationally failed SAP in spring 2025, either during end-of-term or end-of-year evaluations.

1.8 MILLION
students failed to meet SAP requirements in spring 2025
13.1%
of undergraduate students nationally failed SAP in spring 2025
What happens next?

Failing SAP leads many students to lose access to federal aid the next term.

13.1%
of students fail SAP
54.0%
of students who fail lose federal aid for the next term
Who struggles most?

Institutions most often identify low-income, first-generation, and first-year students as those most likely to struggle to meet SAP requirements.

Percentage of institutions indicating the listed group disproportionately struggles with SAP (enrollment-weighted).

36.7%

Low-income students

36.7%

First-generation students

29.1%

First-year students

Why do students struggle?

Challenges often extend beyond academic performance alone.

Percentage of institutions indicating that students commonly say they struggle to meet SAP due to the listed reason (enrollment-weighted).

91.5%
Life circumstances affecting attendance
85.3%
Health challenges
60.3%
Time management issues
51.9%
Insufficient academic preparation
51.6%
Difficulty recovering from early academic setbacks
38.4%
Financial barriers
Which SAP requirements do students fail?

Pace of progress and GPA are the most common barriers.

Percentage of students failing each SAP requirement.

Pace-of-progress requirement: The rate at which students must successfully complete attempted credits to remain on track to finish their program within the maximum time frame. This is most commonly a 67% minimum course completion rate.

GPA requirement: The minimum grade point average students must maintain at each SAP evaluation. For programs longer than two academic years, students generally must have at least a C average (2.0 on a 4.0 scale) or academic standing consistent with the institution’s graduation requirements by the end of the second academic year.

Maximum time frame requirement: The requirement that students be able to complete their program within no more than 150% of the program’s published length, measured in credit hours or calendar time.

Typical SAP requirements and policies

Most students experience a common set of SAP policies.

Percentage of institutions with the following SAP policies (enrollment-weighted).

73%
evaluated SAP at the end of each payment period rather than once per academic year.
96%
required students to have a 2.0 GPA by the end of the second academic year.
91%
required a 67% pace of progress requirement, meaning students must complete 67% of courses.
98%
used 150% for the maximum time frame standard, as opposed to a stricter standard.
95%
used warnings when evaluating SAP more than once per year. When SAP is evaluated at the end of each payment period (rather than at end of the year), institutions can allow students who failed SAP to maintain aid eligibility for one additional term.
100%
allowed students to appeal if they failed SAP.
Where institutions use flexibility

Optional policy choices can make SAP easier or harder to navigate.

Percentage of institutions with the following forms of SAP flexibility (enrollment-weighted).

26.4%

laddered the GPA requirement so that it was lower in the first academic year than the second.

Why it matters: lower GPA thresholds in earlier terms can give students time to adjust to the rigors of college before standards rise.
11.2%

laddered the pace of progress requirement so that it was lower in the first academic year than the second.

Why it matters: lower completion-rate expectations in earlier terms can reduce early SAP pressure.
64.4%

counted developmental coursework toward the maximum time frame standard.

Why it matters: counting these credits can make the maximum time frame requirement harder to meet.

GPA requirement: The minimum grade point average students must maintain at each SAP evaluation. For programs longer than two academic years, students generally must have at least a C average (2.0 on a 4.0 scale) or academic standing consistent with the institution’s graduation requirements by the end of the second academic year.

Pace-of-progress requirement: The rate at which students must successfully complete attempted credits to remain on track to finish their program within the maximum time frame. This is most commonly a 67% minimum course completion rate.

Developmental coursework: Sometimes referred to as remedial courses, developmental courses do not count toward a student’s degree but may be required before taking other college-level courses.

Requirements data is broken out by institutional sector in Appendix C of the report.
Early outreach
68%

Two-thirds of students attend institutions that notify them when they are at risk of failing SAP.

Institutions are required to notify students after they fail SAP, but proactive outreach to at-risk students is optional.

76%2-year institutions
67%4-year public
56%4-year private
Support for students at risk

Academic advising is the most common support offered to students at risk of failing SAP.

Percentage of institutions offering the following supports to students at risk of failing SAP (enrollment-weighted). The sample is limited to institutions that notify students they are at risk of failing SAP.

Referral to academic advising80.4%
Peer tutoring48.1%
Referral to counseling or mental health services45.3%
Encouragement to attend faculty drop-in office hours43.7%
Warnings

Warnings provide a path to maintain aid in the short-term after failing SAP.

Percentage of students who failed SAP who are placed on warning.

26.6%Nationally
26.6%2-year institutions
17.8%4-year public
37.4%4-year private
The appeals gap

Appeals are often successful, but most students who fail SAP never file one.

Appeal filing and approval rates among students who fail SAP, shown nationally and by institution type.

About 1 in 4

students who fail SAP nationally file an appeal

Nationally: 24.2%
About 3 in 4

of appeals filed nationally are approved

Nationally: 74.9%

2-year institutions

18.7%
of students who fail SAP file an appeal
72.1%
of filed appeals are approved

4-year public

26.1%
of students who fail SAP file an appeal
71.0%
of filed appeals are approved

4-year private

26.9%
of students who fail SAP file an appeal
83.1%
of filed appeals are approved
What the pathway looks like

For every 100 students who fail SAP, relatively few file an appeal even though most appeals are approved.

The pathway varies by institution type. Each example begins with 100 students who fail SAP.

Nationally

100
students fail SAP
24
file an appeal
19
have their appeal approved

2-year institutions

100
students fail SAP
19
file an appeal
14
have their appeal approved

4-year public

100
students fail SAP
26
file an appeal
20
have their appeal approved

4-year private

100
students fail SAP
27
file an appeal
24
have their appeal approved
Support during appeals

Students commonly have access to one-on-one guidance and procedural support.

✓
1:1 meeting with financial aid advisor or counselor84.5%
✓
List of valid circumstances for approving an appeal75.4%
✓
List of documentation required to support appeal75.4%
✓
1:1 meeting with academic advisor75.1%
✓
Template for appeal letter or form67.3%
A Missed Opportunity

Students who file SAP appeals get support and preserve access to financial aid; the problem is that most students are missing out on the chance to file an appeal in the first place.